KIEHL’S SUPREMELY GENTLE EYE MAKEUP REMOVERThis lightweight and non-greasy lotion is specifically designed to gently remove makeup without irritating the eye area. It contains cooling cucumber gel, antioxidants, and apricot kernel oil, which can help to moisturize and soften the skin. Apply a small amount of remover to a pad and lightly glide it over your eyelids and eyelashes.Kiehl’s Supremely Gentle Eye Makeup Remover, $16.50L’ORÉAL PARIS CLEAN ARTISTE WATERPROOF & LONG WEARING EYE MAKEUP REMOVERLong-wearing, waterproof eyeliner and mascara are no match for this eye makeup remover. It gently conditions lashes—without the greasy after-feel—while instantly dissolving all traces of eye makeup. What’s more? It’s non-irritating and non-comedogenic.L’Oréal Paris Clean Artiste Clean Artiste Waterproof & Long Wearing Eye Makeup Remover, $6.99LANCÔME EFFACILBe prepared to say goodbye to that smoky eye in a snap. This gentle liquid will cleanse and comfort the eye contour area while whisking away unwanted residue. It’s oil-free too, so no need to worry about a greasy film covering your lids post-use.Lancôme Effacil, $30THE BODY SHOP CAMOMILE GENTLE EYE MAKEUP REMOVERWatch your eye makeup gently melt away with this gentle cleanser. Suitable for all skin types—including sensitive skin and contact lens wearers—the vegan and paraben-free formula will leave your lashes and lids feeling soft and clean.The Body Shop Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover, $18